17 Comments
User's avatar
☆alice's avatar

this is really similar to how i feel about the way that you’ve been treated and had your whole body work rejected over that thing a few months ago

Tara Knight ⚢'s avatar

Let them reject it the real niggas know

Auto_Anon's avatar

“In 1974. Before there was a legal path to gender recognition in most of the United States. Before trans women had any organized political voice at all.” This isn’t true, Rivera and Johnson co-founded the Street Transvestite Action Revolutionaries (STAR) in 1970.

Tara Knight ⚢'s avatar

I stand corrected on this front i had forgotten this took place 4 years before. thank you for the correction!

Auto_Anon's avatar

Just thought it was important to note, a small slip up to make a rhetorical point, but also accidentally erases an important moment for us

Tara Knight ⚢'s avatar

No absolutely please do I welcome criticism it’s the only way trans feminism can develop and expand

Alexis O's avatar

This was a really powerful read. I like how you reclaim your right to separate a thinker’s potential flaws from the usefulness of their ideas. The idea that imperfect frameworks still offer tools for survival is such an honest and grounded way to look at things!

Where I’d gently push for more nuance is around your treatment of the “TERF” label. You make a strong case that it can be used to deflect from critiques of pornography and male power, and I agree that this happens. At the same time, the label is more so directed at feminists who don’t fully align with the dominant positions of gender identity, even when they’re engaging in good faith. From that perspective, calling Dworkin a TERF may genuinely come from a desire to protect trans women, alongside a belief that challenging prevailing views on gender identity is inherently at odds with feminism itself.

Medusa_The_Monster's avatar

That may be how it gets deployed, but TERF was *coined* to seperate radical feminists who excluded us from the category of woman, from the rest of the radical feminists. because we don't know Dworkin's stance, not calling her a TERF makes the most sense, imo - especially since the TERF positioned has consolidated into one that really means Trans Eliminationist Reactionary Feminist, which she undoubtedly wasn't.

Julia Robinson's avatar

The consolidation into Eliminationism is more in the last decade development… by that logic Germaine Greer isn’t a TERF because she just wants total separation from any male influence in society, even though she 100% is

Alexis O's avatar

The piece mentions that “the TERF label, when applied to Dworkin and used as a reason not to read her, functions as a silencing mechanism,” and I agree with that. My point was to expand on why that silencing happens.

In some cases, it can absolutely serve to deflect from engaging with her critiques of sex work. But I also think there are people who use the label, based on the belief that her association with Raymond reflects a position that isn’t fully aligned with dominant views on gender identity today.

So the silencing effect doesn’t always come from the same place. Sometimes it’s strategic, other times it’s rooted in a genuine concern about protecting trans people and maintaining what is seen as a coherent feminist stance. Either way, the outcome can be the same: her work gets dismissed without deeper engagement.

Julia Robinson's avatar

Especially considering the fact that the context around the Raymond book means that Dworkin blurbed a paper that actively calls trans women the same derogatory things we get called now, either knowing what was there and agreeing with it, or without realising because she hadn’t checked

Konnie Staffjord's avatar

This really allowed me to rethink how I approach anti-trans feminist theory, thank you!

Nisindi's avatar

I think it’s up to us as a reader to critically analyse and decide for ourselves what to take or leave in academic texts. Especially when they are older publications. Completely rejecting someone’s works due to not aligning with a small part is silly in itself. We should also think of why and how the author might come to a conclusion that we currently disagree with currently.

The Laborer's avatar

Just found a copy of Life and Death: Unapologetic Writings on the Continuing War Against Women less than twenty four hours after reading this 👀

User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 26
Comment removed
Tara Knight ⚢'s avatar

22nd in new best sellers and you are wasting your time on a 22 year old woman

You are a loser whose understanding of feminism and the woman’s struggle doesn’t exceed that of a 15 year old trad wife on TikTok

Truly horrifying that you even have a book at all

User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 20Edited
Comment removed
Julia Robinson's avatar

I don’t want to think of her as a TERF, but hearing the context in a way makes my view of her worse

User's avatar
Comment removed
May 12
Comment removed
Julia Robinson's avatar

Like... read the articles you blurb BEFORE you put your stamp of approval on it, that's Political Optics 101