Dworkin’s a TERF and You’re a Sexist
Why I, a Black transsexual woman, stan Andrea Dworkin
Every time I mention reading Dworkin, someone wants to have a conversation. Not a conversation in the sense of two people thinking together, a conversation in the sense of a test. They want to know if I understand the danger. If I’ve grappled with her transphobia. If I’m aware that citing her is complicated, fraught, requires the appropriate disclaimers, demands I handle her legacy with the care of someone defusing a bomb rather than reading a book. The implication being that a trans woman who reads Dworkin uncritically is a trans woman who has been tricked into admiring her own executioner.
I am not uncritical. I am also not performing my criticality for your comfort.
I read Dworkin because she is right about the things that matter most to my survival, and I won’t pretend otherwise to manage the feelings of people who have never seriously had to think about whether they’ll make it through the year. The TERF accusation leveled at her is, at best, a massive oversimplification of a genuinely complicated record, and at worst, a politically convenient lie that serves men far more than it serves trans women. The people most eager to make it, the ones who hold up “Dworkin is a TERF” as grounds for dismissing her entire body of work, are not, in my experience, primarily concerned with trans women’s safety. They are concerned with protecting pornography. With protecting men’s access to women’s bodies and labor. With protecting the ideological infrastructure she spent her entire career trying to dismantle. The TERF accusation, in their hands, is a tool for silencing the analysis. Not for protecting us. For protecting the thing she was attacking.
I know this is a bold claim. I also live in a country where 73.7% of all documented trans homicide victims since 2013 have been Black trans women.¹ Black trans women like me. So forgive me if my patience for bad-faith feminist gatekeeping is a little thin right now.
I. Let’s Start With What She Actually Said, Since Nobody Does That
In Woman Hating (1974), her first book, published when she was twenty-seven, before any of this had the vocabulary it has now, Dworkin wrote about trans people with more care, precision, and genuine political solidarity than most feminist writing produced in the five decades since.
She opened the section with a quote from a trans woman friend: “How can I really care if we win ‘the Revolution’? Either way, any way, there will be no place for me.“² She introduced that quote not to dismiss the concern but to center it as the essential problem, what she went on to call the “primary emergency.” Every trans person, she wrote, “white, black, man, woman, rich, poor, is in a state of primary emergency as a transsexual.“³ She argued that the sex binary was a cultural fiction, not a biological fact. She explicitly rejected the framework that blamed trans existence on individual pathology, writing that transsexuality was “caused by a faulty society,” not a faulty person.⁴ And she wrote the line that people who call her a TERF never seem to get around to quoting: “Every transsexual is entitled to a sex-change operation, and it should be provided by the community as one of its functions.“⁵
In 1974. Before there was a legal path to gender recognition in most of the United States. Before trans women had any organized political voice at all. Before the word cisgender existed. Before this particular culture war had its current shape.
She wrote about the trans people she knew in Europe, a “small, vigorously persecuted minority,” she called them, living in “absolute exile,” driven by their ostracization into survival sex, drugs, and suicide. She wrote that their suffering “conjured up for me the deepest reaches of Jewish experience,” and then that it “conjured up for me the deepest reaches of female experience.“⁶ She named what they were living through. She named it as persecution. She named it as emergency. She said the community was responsible for addressing it. She said they were entitled to survive on their own terms.
The TERF case against Dworkin rests on two things. First, a 1979 blurb she wrote for Janice Raymond’s The Transsexual Empire, the book now considered a foundational text of anti-trans feminism. The blurb called it “challenging, rigorous, and pioneering” and described Raymond as asking the hard questions with “intellectual quality and ethical integrity.“⁷ Second, her reported disavowal of parts of the Woman Hating chapter in a 1989 interview with Cindy Jenefsky, though the precise scope of that disavowal, what exactly she renounced and why, is murky.⁸
Both are real. The blurb exists. The disavowal appears to be real, though it comes secondhand through Janice Raymond, who has an obvious stake in Dworkin belonging to her side of this argument, so I am weighing it accordingly. The relationship between Dworkin and Raymond has been contested by everyone who knew Dworkin personally. Her life partner John Stoltenberg says Dworkin “deplored” Raymond’s position and said so at length. Raymond says they were friendly through the writing process and she did not recall any serious disagreement. Martin Duberman’s 2020 biography sides with Stoltenberg.⁹ Raymond disputes Duberman. We are not going to resolve this. Dworkin is dead and cannot clarify, which is a situation everyone involved appears to be making the most of.
The honest account of Dworkin’s position on trans people is: it was complicated, evolved over time, is genuinely contested at the level of biographical fact, and cannot be cleanly resolved into either full ally or confirmed TERF. She was a thinker who worked through difficult problems in public over decades and died before the current form of these debates had fully emerged. She existed at a specific historical moment and wrote from inside it. So did everyone. The question is whether any of this makes her analysis of pornography and male supremacy wrong.
It does not.
II. Who Gets to Decide What Dworkin Means
The effort to claim Dworkin posthumously is not unique to the trans debate. People have been trying to conscript her ghost into their particular cause since approximately the day she died. Conservatives have claimed her pornography work proves they were right about obscenity. Liberal feminists who ignored her for thirty years suddenly rediscovered her when her analysis became useful for attacking sex work. TERFs have claimed her as their founding theorist. Trans allies have claimed her as a proto-supporter. Everyone, it turns out, wants the most ferocious feminist intellectual of the twentieth century on their side. The desire is understandable. The resulting discourse is a mess.
What is less understandable is the specific deployment against trans women: using the contested and genuinely ambiguous question of Dworkin’s personal views on transsexuality to void an entire body of political analysis that does not actually depend on those views. The analysis of pornography as a mechanism of social control does not require Dworkin to have held correct opinions about trans identity. The analysis of the family as a site of women’s exploited labor does not depend on her having been kind to trans people in 1979. The argument that male supremacy is enforced through violence against women who refuse the terms it offers for their survival does not become false because she blurbed a bad book.
The TERF accusation, when used to dismiss her work in its entirety, does not work as an intellectual argument. It works as a social sanction. It tells the reader: proximity to this text marks you as a bad person. And bad people don’t have to be engaged. This is useful for anyone who wants to avoid engaging with the analysis, especially if they are directly implicated by it. Pornographers were very motivated to dismiss Dworkin. Liberal men who wanted to feel enlightened while consuming pornography were very motivated to dismiss Dworkin. The people who called her a man-hating, sex-hating, physically grotesque hysteric during her lifetime were not primarily motivated by concern for women’s wellbeing. They were motivated by the threat her analysis posed to their arrangements.
The posthumous trans-TERF accusation is the updated version of the same mechanism. Sleeker. More progressive-sounding. Harder to identify as what it is: men and their allies using trans women as cover to protect themselves from a critique of their behavior.
III. The Record Actually Before Us on Raymond
Since we’re doing the Dworkin biography, let’s also do the Raymond biography, because the two are usually discussed as though Raymond’s views are some abstract feminist position rather than a specific set of claims that have actual, documented, material consequences.
Janice Raymond wrote The Transsexual Empire in 1979 as her doctoral dissertation, under the supervision of Mary Daly, which, if you know anything about Mary Daly, tells you something about the intellectual environment.¹⁰ The book argued that trans women were not women but rather men colonizing womanhood, that their presence in feminist spaces was an act of infiltration, and that, in what remains the most directly harmful sentence in the book, “all transsexuals rape women’s bodies by reducing the real female form to an artifact, appropriating this body for themselves.“¹¹
Let me be precise about what “all transsexuals rape women’s bodies” means as a political claim. It means that my existence is an act of violence. Not my behavior, my existence. Raymond is saying that the simple fact of my being a woman constitutes a rape of cis women. This is not a nuanced position that requires careful contextualization. It is a claim that trans women are rapists by virtue of existing, and it was influential enough to be cited in U.S. policy documents that shaped access to healthcare for trans people throughout the 1980s. The Health and Human Services exclusion of gender-affirming care from Medicare coverage, which stood until 2014, was informed by a Raymond-authored report.¹² People died because of that policy. That is not rhetorical, it is the material history of the book.
Sandy Stone, a trans woman who had worked as a sound engineer for the feminist collective Olivia Records, was named and attacked personally in The Transsexual Empire. Raymond’s writing about Stone contributed to pressure that eventually led Stone to leave Olivia.¹³ Stone responded in 1987 with “The Empire Strikes Back: A Posttranssexual Manifesto,” now considered a founding text of transgender studies, which is probably not the legacy Raymond was hoping for. If you’re going to get roasted in the academic literature, getting roasted into a foundational text of an entire field is at least efficient.
None of this means Raymond was wrong about everything she ever wrote. She has done serious work on reproductive exploitation and sex trafficking. But The Transsexual Empire is not a nuanced document that requires careful reading against its historical context in order to understand the harm it did. The harm is the historical context. The book told feminists that trans women were dangerous to them. Some feminists believed it. Trans women were excluded from feminist spaces, harassed, threatened, denied healthcare and housing and political solidarity. The ideas in that book had consequences that continued for decades, and some of those consequences are still ongoing.
Dworkin blurbed it. I don’t think that makes Dworkin irredeemable. I think it makes her a person who made a wrong call, probably more than once, in a long life of political engagement. Dworkin also made incorrect arguments about other things, the final chapter of Woman Hating contains positions she herself later rejected, including some that have nothing to do with trans people and everything to do with the occasionally chaotic intellectual enthusiasms of a brilliant twenty-seven-year-old writing her first book.¹⁴ People are allowed to be complicated and still have their best work matter. If we required feminist thinkers to have held correct positions on every question before we engaged their analysis, we would have almost no feminist theory to engage.
IV. What the Accusation Is Actually Doing
The TERF label, when applied to Dworkin specifically and used as a reason not to read her, is a silencing mechanism. The people it silences are not just Dworkin scholars or radical feminist academics, it silences trans women who find her work useful. It tells us we have been fooled. That our reading is naive. That we should look elsewhere, somewhere safer, somewhere more approved, somewhere that won’t make anyone uncomfortable.
Uncomfortable for whom?
When I read Dworkin on pornography, I am not uncomfortable. I am recognized. When she writes that pornography is “the essential sexuality of male power: of hate, of ownership, of hierarchy; of sadism, of dominance,“¹⁵ she is describing something I have lived in my body, the way male entitlement to women’s sexuality operates as a baseline cultural assumption, the way that assumption becomes violence when it meets refusal, the way the violence is then justified by the ideology that produced the entitlement.
Since 2013, the Human Rights Campaign has documented 372 murders of transgender and gender-expansive people in the United States. 73.7% of those victims, 274 people, were Black trans women.¹⁶ The majority were killed by people they knew, in the context of romantic or sexual relationships. Nearly half of murders with known perpetrators were committed by intimate partners, family members, or friends.¹⁷ Black trans women are killed, on average, five years younger than non-Black trans women.¹⁸ The estimated life expectancy for transgender women in the Americas is between thirty and thirty-five years.¹⁹
These women were killed primarily by men. They were killed primarily in the context of sexual pursuit or intimate relationships that became dangerous when the men involved decided, for whatever reason, that the terms they had expected were not being met. The men who killed them were operating inside an ideology that says women’s bodies are available, that trans women’s existence is a kind of trick, that the discovery of our transness is a provocation that justifies violence. That ideology has a name. Dworkin spent her entire career analyzing it.
The TERF accusation tells trans women not to use that analysis. The women dying at thirty-two do not have the luxury of discarding tools because they came from complicated sources.
V. The Pornography Argument Is Ours
The specific argument Dworkin made about pornography, and that gets her dismissed most often, because it is the most threatening, is not difficult to understand and does not require feminist credentials to evaluate. She argued that pornography is not a representation of sex but an expression of power: the power of men over women, inscribed in imagery, distributed at scale, absorbed into culture, and used to teach the premise that women’s bodies are available for use, that women’s suffering is entertainment, that women’s refusal is a minor obstacle rather than a fact about their personhood.²⁰
This is not a claim about individual pornography consumers being evil. It is a structural argument about what an ideology, when distributed and absorbed at scale, does to the social environment in which women try to live. Dworkin understood that ideology is not propaganda delivered to passive recipients, it is the water in which culture swims. Men who grew up inside a culture saturated with the premise of women’s sexual availability do not need to consciously endorse that premise in order to act on it. It shapes expectation. It shapes the interpretation of refusal. It shapes the calculus of anger when refusal occurs.
For trans women specifically, the pornography that codes us as objects for a specific male gaze, as deception, as novelty, as humiliation, directly informs how the men who consume it then treat us in person. There is a category of pornography built around the “discovery” of trans women’s anatomy as a joke or a threat. There is a genre in which our existence is framed as something men have been tricked into wanting. The men who kill trans women after sexual encounters are often, in their own accounts, enacting this script. They say they were tricked. They say they felt humiliated. They say they felt their masculinity was threatened. The ideology told them that our existence was a violation of something they were owed. Dworkin, in 1981, was naming the factory that produces that ideology.
The pornography industry does not like Dworkin. It did not like her when she was alive and it does not like her now. Her analysis named exactly what was happening in that industry and precisely why it was harmful, and the industry responded by funding her caricature, spreading rumors about her personal life, and manufacturing the figure of the hysterical, sex-hating prude who thought all sex was rape, which she never said and which anyone who has read her knows she never said, though the number of people who repeat this while obviously never having opened one of her books is really something to behold.
The TERF accusation has been a useful addition to the toolkit because it allows her dismissal to come from a progressive-sounding place. You’re not just protecting pornography anymore, you’re protecting trans women. Never mind that the trans women supposedly being protected have no say in this, that many of us read Dworkin and find her useful, that the specific trans women most harmed by male sexual violence are the ones her analysis most directly addresses. The performance of protecting us is doing the work of protecting the industry. I am not grateful for this.
VI. Liberal Men Are Not Our Friends, a Brief Chapter
The pattern of men using progressive language to shield themselves from feminist critique is not new. It predates the TERF wars. It predates Dworkin. It has been a feature of left-wing political culture since approximately the moment women tried to name their experiences within left-wing political culture and were told they were complicating the real struggle.
In the sixties and seventies, women in New Left organizations who raised concerns about their treatment were told they were being divisive. Women who named the sexual exploitation they experienced inside supposedly liberatory spaces were accused of damaging the movement. The sexual revolution, marketed as freedom, was in practice often freedom for men, freedom from women’s refusal, freedom from the expectation of care. Dworkin wrote about this directly in Pornography and Right-Wing Women and everywhere else: the left’s adoption of sexual liberation as a cause was not incidentally convenient for men. It was structurally convenient for men. It placed women’s objections to their treatment in direct conflict with the movement’s stated values.²¹
The contemporary version of this dynamic runs as follows: a man who is invested in pornography, or in the politics that protect pornography, or more broadly in the premise that women’s sexuality is a resource he is entitled to access, finds that Dworkin’s analysis names him. He could engage the analysis. Instead, he produces a progressive-sounding reason why the analysis should be dismissed. The TERF argument is that reason. It allows him to position himself as trans-affirming while dismissing the feminist thinker who most precisely described the ideology driving violence against trans women.
If you are a man doing this, and you may not even realize you are doing it, ideology is very good at making its own operations invisible, you should sit with what you are actually protecting. The analysis that names the mechanism killing Black trans women at thirty-two is not your enemy. Your comfort with the mechanism is your enemy. These are different things.
VII. The Dismissal Has a History
Dworkin was dismissed during her lifetime through every misogynist tactic available. She was called man-hating, sex-hating, humorless, dangerous, crazy, a fraud. Her physical appearance was weaponized constantly, she wore overalls and was fat and Jewish and refused to perform femininity for the comfort of people who hated her, and this was treated as evidence of pathology rather than dignity. The pornography industry, which had direct financial incentive to destroy her credibility, ran concerted campaigns against her.²² The caricature, fat, crazy, man-hating Dworkin who thought all sex was rape, was manufactured and distributed by people whose business model depended on her analysis being ignored.
She knew this. She wrote about it. She was not naive about how power works or how women who name it are treated. “Feminism is hated because women are hated,” she wrote in Right-Wing Women. “Anti-feminism is a direct expression of misogyny; it is the political defense of women hating.“²³ She was describing her own treatment while analyzing the mechanism that produced it. The woman had range.
The posthumous TERF accusation is a cleaner operation than the lifetime caricature. It does not have to call her fat or crazy. It gets to position itself as principled, as protective, as concerned with the wellbeing of a marginalized group. It borrows the moral authority of trans liberation, a liberation whose material stakes are demonstrated by those murder statistics I keep citing, and uses it to shut down analysis of male supremacy. This is elegant as political maneuvering. It is also straightforwardly dishonest about what it is doing and why.
The fact that some trans people have internalized this dismissal and repeat it does not make it right. Marginalized people absorb and reproduce the ideologies of the systems that oppress them, this is not a controversial claim, it is basic political analysis. Trans women who have been told since childhood that our existence is pathological, that our femininity is performance, that we are by definition less fully women than cis women, have absorbed a lot of messaging that does not serve us. Some of that messaging includes the framing that Dworkin’s analysis of male supremacy is not for us, does not apply to us, or was made by someone who hated us. The framing benefits people who have a stake in us not using that analysis. I am pointing this out because I have internalized plenty of harmful messaging in my own life and I know how invisible it can be until someone names it from the outside.
VIII. What She Gets Wrong
Dworkin’s framework for understanding gender was developed inside a specific moment in radical feminism that had significant blindspots about trans experience, and some of those blindspots produced analysis that was wrong in ways that matter.
Her vision of gender abolition, the idea that dismantling the sex binary would eventually render transsexuality as she understood it unnecessary, that trans people were responding to an oppressive gender system and would be freed from that response by the system’s destruction, is a vision that does not match the evidence from trans people’s actual experience. The idea that trans identity is entirely a product of socialization and would disappear in a world without gender roles has been tested by trans people trying to live genderqueer or gender-neutral lives as an alternative to transition. It mostly does not work.²⁴ Gender dysphoria does not respond to ideological commitment in that way. Whatever is happening in trans experience, and the accounts are varied and the science is genuinely complicated and contested, it is not simply a reaction to gender roles that can be dissolved by changing the roles.
Dworkin’s position on this, insofar as it can be established, was a position of her time, shaped by seventies radical feminist theory, informed by the trans people she knew, who were mostly trans women living extremely precarious lives in Europe, forced into survival sex, driven to drugs and suicide, and not updated by the subsequent fifty years of trans scholarship, trans political organizing, and trans people speaking about their experiences on their own terms. She was working with what she had. What she had was inadequate. This is not a moral failing. It is the condition of being a person in a specific historical moment.
The strand of radical feminism that inherited her framework and used it to justify active exclusion and harm of trans women is a different matter. That strand took the inadequacies in her analysis and weaponized them, producing a politics that has contributed to real harm. The Michigan Womyn’s Music Festival exclusion of trans women. The knife threats at the West Coast Lesbian Conference.²⁵ The decades of exclusion from feminist organizing, from legal protections, from healthcare. The Raymond report that shaped Medicare policy. These are not abstract theoretical positions. They are events with documented consequences, and some of those consequences were people dying.
Dworkin did not create this tradition, and she is not straightforwardly responsible for it. She wrote a blurb for a bad book. She may or may not have held, in the last decade of her life, positions more sympathetic to Raymond than to Stoltenberg’s account of her. The tradition that followed built a politics on misreadings and extensions of her work that she may or may not have endorsed. We cannot know for certain. What we can say is that the politics built in her name, by people claiming her framework, has done real harm to trans women, and that harm should be named as harm rather than defended as feminist principle.
This is what it means to read her critically. Not to dismiss her. Not to declare the entire body of work contaminated. But to say: this part is wrong, this part was weaponized, this part caused harm, and this other part, this analysis of pornography and male supremacy and the family as a site of women’s exploitation, is correct and necessary and particularly relevant to the women being killed at thirty-two.
IX. The Analysis Is Ours by Right
The HRC has documented that 42% of trans people killed by known perpetrators are killed by romantic partners, sexual partners, friends, or family.²⁶ Half of trans homicides documented by one study were at the hands of people the victim had been sexually intimate with.²⁷ The men who kill us are not strangers acting on abstract hatred. They are often men who knew us, men who pursued us, men whose desire for us coexisted with an ideology that told them our existence was a problem that could be resolved through violence.
Dworkin’s analysis of how male sexual violence works, how it is not aberrant but structural, how it emerges from an ideology that organizes men’s relationship to women’s bodies, how that ideology is produced and reproduced through pornography and the family and every institution invested in women’s sexual availability, is directly relevant to understanding why we die the way we die, at the hands of the people who die alongside us.
The claim that her analysis does not apply to trans women, or that we should not use it, asks us to discard the most precise description of the mechanism killing us. In exchange we are offered an identity politics that is very good at producing affirmative language in diversity statements and very bad at keeping Black trans women alive. A politics that has made its peace with the system Dworkin was trying to dismantle, and which uses the language of trans inclusion to insulate that system from the critique it deserves.
We didn’t get access to this analysis because Dworkin was perfectly trans-affirming. We got access to it because she was right about male supremacy. We should use what we were given.
X. A Note on the Sexism Charge
The title of this essay contains a charge. I will defend it here.
Men who invoke trans solidarity as a reason to dismiss Dworkin’s analysis of pornography and male supremacy are being sexist. The mechanism is direct: find a progressive-sounding argument for dismissing feminist critique of male behavior, deploy it to avoid engaging the critique, continue the behavior the critique was describing. This is what dismissing Dworkin as a TERF, when done in the context of defending pornography, or defending the arrangement of women’s sexual availability to men, or more broadly defending any aspect of male supremacy she was targeting, actually is. The language of trans protection is being used to protect male prerogative.
This is not a claim about all critics of Dworkin or all people who have concerns about her trans politics. There are genuine critiques to be made. Trans feminist scholars have made them thoughtfully, from inside a commitment to both trans liberation and feminist analysis of power. Those critiques are not what I am describing. I am describing a specific move: using the trans question to void the pornography analysis, the family analysis, the argument that women are a class systematically subordinated by male supremacy. Using trans women as the reason this analysis cannot be heard. While doing nothing, concretely, for trans women.
If you are a man who has done this: you have used us as cover. You have not protected us. You have protected yourself from an analysis that applies to you. The fact that the cover story involved our welfare makes it worse, not better.
XI. What I Take From Her, and Why
I stan Dworkin not despite being a Black transsexual woman but because of it. Because I am precisely the kind of woman whose existence her analysis best explains and whose survival her politics most urgently demands.
Her analysis of pornography tells me why men feel entitled to my body and why they become violent when I decline to be what they expected. Her analysis of the family tells me why I have no economic safety net, why there are so few structures built to catch me when I fall, why the state’s interest in my welfare is approximately zero, and why the women most likely to be found dead at thirty-two are the ones who had no family structure to absorb the cost of their existence. Her argument that male supremacy is organized violence, not the pathology of individual bad actors but a system with incentives and institutions and cultural infrastructure, tells me why my community is under siege and why the siege is not some aberration but a predictable feature of the arrangement.
What she gets wrong, I work with. Her framework needed extensions she didn’t make. The analysis of trans experience in Woman Hating is compassionate and wrong in equal measure, she saw the persecution, named it correctly, and misidentified the solution. That the solution she identified was later used as a weapon against us is something she cannot be entirely held responsible for, though the history is the history. The worst elements of what was done in her name were done by people who extended her framework in directions she may never have intended and that her partner says she would have opposed.
The whole mess is complicated and I am not going to pretend otherwise, because pretending otherwise in either direction, either the clean vindication or the clean condemnation, would be dishonest, and Dworkin was not someone who had much patience for dishonesty even when the truth was ugly.
I will say this: I would rather work with an imperfect analysis of the actual problem than with a perfect analysis of a comfortable abstraction. The actual problem is that men are organized, systemically, to treat women, all women, trans women particularly, Black trans women most particularly, as resources to be used and disposed of. The actual problem is that the ideology producing that organization is manufactured, distributed, and defended by powerful interests. The actual problem is that the women who pay the highest price for this arrangement are the ones with the fewest alternatives and the least institutional protection. Dworkin named this problem with more precision and more fury than almost anyone before or since. The fury was not incidental. It was appropriate.
The TERF accusation tells me to look away. I am not looking away. I am reading, and thinking, and refusing to let my tools be taken from me by people who need me unarmed. The analysis is ours. We did not earn it because anyone gave it to us generously. We earned it because we live inside the thing she was describing and we need every accurate description of it we can get.
She spent her life trying to name the mechanism killing us. She did not do it perfectly. She did not do it for us, specifically, we were mostly invisible to her, the way trans women have been mostly invisible to the feminist movements that were not built for us. But the mechanism she named is the one we are inside.
I will take my tools where I find them, thank you. And if someone wants to argue I should discard Dworkin’s analysis of the pornography that produced the ideology that killed three-quarters of the trans women murdered in this country over the past decade, I am going to need a much better argument than “she blurbed a bad book in 1979.”
We do not have the luxury of that kind of purity. We are busy trying to stay alive.
Sources
Human Rights Campaign Foundation, “Fatal Violence Against the Transgender and Gender Non-Conforming Community in the United States,” 2024 report. https://www.hrc.org/press-releases/hrcs-2024-epidemic-of-violence-report
Andrea Dworkin, Woman Hating (New York: E.P. Dutton, 1974), p. 185, quoting a trans woman friend. As cited in Woman Hating Wikipedia entry and John Stoltenberg, “Andrea Dworkin Was a Trans Ally,” Boston Review, April 6, 2020.
Dworkin, Woman Hating, p. 186, as quoted in Stoltenberg, Boston Review, 2020; The Conversations Project, TransAdvocate.
Ibid., p. 186: “More probably transsexuality is caused by a faulty society.”
Ibid., p. 186.
Ibid., p. 185. Full passage cited in multiple sources including Tablet Magazine, Stoltenberg’s Medium essay (2014/2021), and RationalWiki entry on Andrea Dworkin.
Dworkin blurb for Janice Raymond, The Transsexual Empire (1979 paperback edition), as quoted in Phyllis Chesler, “Andrea Revised,” Dignity: A Journal of Sexual Exploitation and Violence 6, no. 1 (2021); Tablet Magazine, “Woke Andrea Dworkin,” April 2021.
Cindy Jenefsky interview with Dworkin (1989), as cited in Raymond, Doublethink (Spinifex Press, 2021), pp. 41-47, excerpted in Women Are Human, and discussed in “Raymond Sets the Record Straight,” Intense World Theory.
Martin Duberman, Andrea Dworkin: The Feminist as Revolutionary (New York: Basic Books, 2020), p. 161; John Stoltenberg, “Andrea Dworkin Was Not Transphobic,” originally Feminist Times, 2014, republished Medium, 2021; Chesler, “Andrea Revised,” 2021.
Wikipedia, “The Transsexual Empire”; Wikipedia, “Janice Raymond.”
Janice Raymond, The Transsexual Empire: The Making of the She-Male (Boston: Beacon Press, 1979), p. 104. The “rape women’s bodies” claim is also cited in Scholar & Feminist Online; Wikipedia, Transsexual Empire.
The Raymond-authored report informing HHS Medicare exclusions is documented in multiple trans history sources; see also Wikipedia, “The Transsexual Empire.”
Sandy Stone’s situation at Olivia Records and subsequent “Empire Strikes Back” response: Wikipedia, “The Transsexual Empire”; Wikipedia, “Sandy Stone.”
Jenefsky interview on Woman Hating chapter disavowal, as cited in Raymond and discussed in Intense World Theory.
Andrea Dworkin, Pornography: Men Possessing Women (New York: Plume/Penguin, 1989 [1981]), p. 24.
HRC Foundation, 2024 Epidemic of Violence report. 372 total victims; 274 (73.7%) Black trans women.
HRC Foundation, Fatal Violence 2024. “42% of victims with a known killer were killed by a romantic/sexual partner, friend, or family member.” Insider database (2022) cited in Wikipedia, “Violence against transgender people in the United States”: “half were killed by people they’d been sexually intimate with.”
Pamuela Halliwell et al., “Characterizing the Prevalence and Perpetrators of Documented Fatal Violence Against Black Transgender Women in the United States (2013-2021),” Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 2025. “Black transgender women are, on average, 5 years younger than non-Black transgender women when they are murdered.”
Ibid., citing Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (2014) on life expectancy of 30-35 years.
Andrea Dworkin, “Pornography Happens to Women,” speech at University of Chicago Law School, March 6, 1993. In The Price We Pay, eds. Lederer and Delgado (New York: Hill and Wang, 1995).
Andrea Dworkin, Pornography: Men Possessing Women; Right-Wing Women (New York: Perigee/Putnam, 1983).
The campaign against Dworkin by the pornography industry is documented in multiple sources; see Dworkin’s own accounts in Letters from a War Zone (1993) and in her speeches.
Andrea Dworkin, Right-Wing Women (1983), as quoted in Goodreads and multiple secondary sources.
John Stoltenberg’s Medium essay discusses one trans commenter’s personal experience attempting genderqueer identity as alternative to transition and its failure; this is also addressed in the Conversations Project.
The West Coast Lesbian Conference incident, where Robin Tyler physically protected a trans woman from sex essentialist activists and was herself assaulted, is documented in The Conversations Project, TransAdvocate.
HRC Foundation, Fatal Violence 2024: “42% of victims with a known killer were killed by a romantic/sexual partner, friend, or family member.”
Insider database (2022), as cited in Wikipedia, “Violence against transgender people in the United States”: “half were killed by people they’d been sexually intimate with, over a third were unsolved.”
Donate to my Ko-fi: https://ko-fi.com/bundleofstyyx

this is really similar to how i feel about the way that you’ve been treated and had your whole body work rejected over that thing a few months ago
“In 1974. Before there was a legal path to gender recognition in most of the United States. Before trans women had any organized political voice at all.” This isn’t true, Rivera and Johnson co-founded the Street Transvestite Action Revolutionaries (STAR) in 1970.