The Psychology of the Becky
chasers, mistresses, and why it’s so easy to rape a trans woman.
This essay is free to read. Paid subscriptions and donations are genuinely how I cover groceries and keep this going full time, so if the work means something to you, I’d really appreciate it.
You can support the work and donate here here: https://ko-fi.com/bundleofstyyx
Follow Bundle of Styx elsewhere: Instagram @bundleof.styx, Twitter: @Bundleofstyyx, Bluesky Bundleofstyx.org, TikTok @Bundleof.styx, Tumblr: bundleofstx, and YouTube: @bundleofstyyx.
Somewhere underneath the tote bag, the pronoun circle, and the trans women are women sticker on her water bottle, she didn’t quite believe it, and the unbelief was the part that turned her on. Her name was Elise.
She had the sticker, obviously. Silver water bottle, dented near the bottom, covered in evidence. A union sticker. A little Audre Lorde quote. One that said dykes against borders. The trans one sat near the top, peeling at the edge from being washed too many times in whatever co-op sink she’d been standing over that week.
I met her at a fundraiser in a queer bar with bad lighting and a bathroom door that didn’t lock. Someone had set up a folding table near the bathrooms with zines, buttons, and a jar labeled CASH FOR COMRADES. The room smelled like beer, wet wool, and people trying very hard to be good.
Elise noticed me before I noticed her. Women like that look at you in a way that teaches you the difference between being seen and being selected.
I was standing by the wall, pretending to read a flyer about tenant organizing while calculating whether I had enough money for a second drink and my estrogen prescription. I did not. The math was rude, so I stopped doing it.
“You’re Mara, right?” she asked, holding two plastic cups, one of them apparently for me. This is how they start, by handing you things you didn’t ask for and making refusal feel like a small act of cruelty. I said, “Depends who’s asking,” and she smiled.
“I’m Elise. I read your piece on queer housing.”
“Sorry to hear that.”
She handed me the drink. “No, I loved it. It was brutal.”
That was the first word. Brutal. A woman who likes your argument says it helped her think. A woman who likes what your argument lets her feel says it was brutal, like you’re weather, like the point of you is impact.
Still, I took the drink. I was broke, tired, and not above being flattered by a pretty woman with correct politics and strong shoulders. Humanity limps forward this way, unfortunately.
We talked for forty minutes, which is the exact amount of time before anything true has to happen. It’s the sweet spot where everyone is still whoever they came dressed as.
Elise told me she worked at a nonprofit that helped queer youth access resources, a sentence vague enough to cover either lifesaving work or sending Google Docs into the void. She’d gone to a women’s college. She’d dropped out of a PhD program because academia was “too extractive.” She lived with three roommates, two cats, and an ex she described as “basically family,” which meant the ex still paid half the bills and cried in the kitchen twice a month.
She asked about my writing. She asked about my transition. She asked about my name.
“Did Mara come before or after?” she asked.
I knew what she meant, so I said, “After.”
She looked at me for a second. “It suits you.”
A name isn’t a dress. It doesn’t suit you because it flatters the shape of what someone thinks you became. But she said it softly, and I let the irritation pass.
Later, leaning close so I could hear her over the music, she said, “You have this presence. It’s different.”
Nobody ever means your soul when they say presence. They mean your height, your voice, your hands, your jaw, the history they imagine clinging to you like perfume. Presence is what people call the body when they want to sound deeper than they are.
“Different from what?” I asked.
She blinked. “Just different.”
“From cis women?”
She laughed too quickly. “That’s not what I meant.”
A few weeks later, in her bed, she almost said it plainly. We were half-dressed, half-asleep, one of those nights where nobody has enough shame left to keep their theology organized. She was tracing little circles against my ribs, watching her own hand move over me like she was reading something written under the skin.
“You’re kind of…” she started.
I looked at her. “Kind of what?”
She smiled, embarrassed, but not embarrassed enough to stop. “I don’t know. It’s stupid.”
“Most things are. Continue.”
She laughed and pressed her face into my shoulder. “You’re like the best of both worlds.”
There it was. The phrase. The little chaser fortune cookie. Best of both worlds.
I went still, and she felt it immediately.
“I didn’t mean it like that,” she said.
“How did you mean it?”
“I just mean you’re soft, but you’re also…” She stopped herself, which was worse than finishing. “You have this strength. This intensity.”
“Presence?”
She looked relieved, because I’d given her the polite word. “Yeah. Presence.”
She kissed me before I could make her define it. That was one of her tricks. Not a cruel one, exactly. A human one. She could turn an unfinished sentence into a mouth on your neck and make you forget, for a few minutes, that the sentence was still sitting there with its shoes on.
“Best of both worlds” is never a compliment. It’s a receipt. It means she’s split you into parts and decided the combination benefits her. It means woman enough to keep her politics clean, close enough to whatever she imagines manhood left behind to keep the sex charged. It means she’s found a way to eroticize the whole of you while refusing the wholeness of you. Your face, your voice, your hands, your breasts, your height, your softness, your history, your hormones, your fear, your pride, your passing and your not-passing, all of it gets turned into a curated contradiction for her to enjoy.
The sentence she’d never say out loud is the one her hands kept writing: I want the parts of a woman and the ghost of a man arranged in a way that makes me feel daring without making me feel straight.
That’s why the phrase lands so badly. It sounds like praise. What it hands you is a floor plan, showing you exactly where she intends to keep every part of you.
Black women have an old name for the woman who runs a house like that.
That first night, it was exactly what she meant. But the night was warm, and she was pretty, and the drink she bought me was stronger than the ones I bought myself, so I did what women do when they already know the answer and want a few more minutes before paying for it.
I let her touch my arm.
i. The Forty-Minute Girl
Attraction and chasing look identical from across a bar, which is exactly the problem. A woman who’s attracted to you wants your Tuesday. She wants to know what you’re like with a head cold, what you do when your card gets declined at the pharmacy, whether you’re a sore loser at board games. A woman who’s chasing you wants your Friday night, specifically the forty minutes after the second drink and before either of you has said anything true.
Elise was wonderful on Fridays. On Fridays she wanted me in the back corner of bars, in bathroom lines, on her couch while some movie neither of us cared about played unwatched. On Fridays she looked at me like I’d opened a door she’d been pretending not to stand beside. She wanted the charge. The atmosphere. The sensation of standing slightly outside her own biography for one evening, the way other people rent a convertible.
But she wasn’t only that. That’s the part that made it hard. If she’d been a monster, I could’ve written the story faster.
She kissed me for the first time near the hallway wall between the jukebox and the exit sign, one hand on my waist, the other pressed beside my head. Her mouth tasted like gin and lime. Her hair brushed my cheek. I remember thinking, stupidly, that this must be what other women had been doing all this time while I was busy surviving my own face.
She pulled back first and said, “You’re beautiful.”
I laughed because I didn’t know what to do with that yet.
“No, Mara,” she said. “I mean it.”
That was how she got in, and it had nothing to do with politics or language. She got in through repetition. Through the way she said my name like it had always belonged to me. Through the way she touched the small of my back in public, casually, like there was no scandal there. Through the way she called me “my girl” while handing me coffee in bed.
I’d been called brave. I’d been called fierce. I’d been called stunning by women who meant “interesting injury.” I’d been called valid by people who should’ve been fined for emotional littering.
Elise called me sleepy.
“Come here, sleepy girl,” she would say on Saturday mornings, already awake, already reading something dense and underlined. Sleepy girl. Messy girl. Pretty girl. My girl.
A person can live on very little if she’s been starved long enough.
Three months in, I brought the vial to her apartment in the paper pharmacy bag because my hands had started shaking whenever I tried to do the shot myself. I’d watched the videos. I’d read the instructions. I’d stared at my thigh until it stopped feeling like a thigh and became a legal dispute between my body and my nerve endings.
Elise opened the door in sweatpants and a little black tank top, hair clipped up, glasses on.
“You brought it?” she asked.
I held up the bag, and she smiled. “Come in.”
Her kitchen was small and warm. She cleared the table, laid out the alcohol swabs, the syringe, the needle, the bandage. The vial sat between us, tiny and gold.
I sat with my shorts pulled up and my leg exposed. Elise washed her hands twice. She got serious when she was nervous. Her mouth went small. Her eyebrows drew together. It made me love her in a way I didn’t have permission to love her yet.
“You don’t have to,” I said.
“I want to.”
“Don’t say it like you’re volunteering for Habitat for Humanity.”
She laughed, and the sound loosened something in my chest.
Then she knelt in front of me. There are moments you only recognize as erotic years later, because when they happen they’re too tender to survive being named. Her fingers cool against my thigh. Her face close enough that I could feel her breath. The needle in her hand. My body waiting to be helped across a border it had been walking toward alone for years.
“Tell me if you need me to stop,” she said.
“I won’t.”
“Mara.”
“I won’t.”
She looked up at me, and there was no joke left in the room.
“You’re allowed to be scared.”
That was the first time I cried in front of her. She wiped my cheek with her thumb and didn’t make a speech about it. That was the part that undid me. She didn’t tell me I was brave. She didn’t say she was honored. She didn’t make my fear into her moral experience. She just held my thigh, waited until my breathing steadied, and slid the needle in.
It barely hurt.
“Done,” she whispered.
Afterward she kissed the bandage. Then my thigh. Then the place just above it, slower, warmer, until my embarrassment turned into something else and my whole body went loose, one held muscle at a time. She climbed into my lap carefully, like I was precious, like I was breakable in a way that made her more careful rather than more powerful.
“My girl,” she said.
And I believed her. God help me, I believed her.
For a while, we were happy. Not in the clean way people describe after the fact when they’re trying to save face. It was dirty happy. Human happy. Too-much-pasta happy. Bodega-flowers-in-a-jar happy. Happy with overdraft fees and wet socks and one good lipstick shared between us because Elise swore the shade looked better on me, then pouted when it did.
She took me to a diner at two in the morning after a reading where I’d bombed so badly I considered changing my name again out of principle. She ordered pancakes and fries because she had the palate of a gifted toddler, then fed me fries across the table while I sulked.
“You didn’t bomb,” she said.
“I absolutely bombed.”
“You were received unevenly.”
“That’s lesbian for bombed.”
She snorted into her coffee.
I loved making her laugh. It made her look unguarded. For a second, her politics, her haircut, her little rings, all of it slipped. She became just a woman in a diner at two in the morning, kicking my ankle under the table.
“You’re mean,” she said.
“I’m precise.”
“You’re impossible.”
“And yet.”
She smiled. “And yet.”
She paid for the pancakes because I was broke. She paid like it was ordinary, like my poverty wasn’t a moral inconvenience, like letting her cover dinner didn’t turn me into a project. None of it felt patronizing yet. I loved her for that too.
We had cute dates, which sounds obscene now, like complimenting the trap’s upholstery. We went to a museum on a free Sunday and made up crimes for every woman in every portrait.
“She poisoned her husband,” Elise said, pointing at a woman in blue satin.
“No, she poisoned her husband’s brother and blamed the husband.”
“Dark.”
“Look at her face. She’s efficient.”
Elise leaned her head on my shoulder in front of a painting of two women beside a river. Her hand found mine. She didn’t look around first. She didn’t check who was watching. She just held it.
Outside, we split a pretzel from a cart and got mustard on our sleeves. She wiped mine off with her thumb. I pretended not to melt into the sidewalk.
Once, we spent an entire afternoon doing laundry because my apartment machine was broken and her building had three washers in the basement. She sat on top of a dryer reading while I folded my clothes badly.
“You fold like a man,” she said, and I threw a sock at her face.
She froze as soon as she realized what she’d said.
“I’m sorry,” she said. “I didn’t mean…”
I should’ve listened to the panic in her apology. Instead I laughed.
“Relax. My folding is transmisogynistic. We can admit that.”
She looked relieved. Too relieved. Then she slid down from the dryer, came over, and showed me how to fold the shirt properly.
“Corners together,” she said. “Like this.”
I watched her hands. Long fingers. Chipped red polish. A scar near her thumb from some kitchen accident she’d turned into an anecdote. She folded my shirt, then another.
Domesticity is evil because it knows exactly where to touch you. I’d spent years imagining womanhood as a mirror, a prescription, a name, a surgery, a war. I hadn’t expected it to arrive in a basement laundry room while a woman I loved folded my shirts like she planned to keep seeing them.
She made me feel like a woman, which is the part I hate admitting, and I hate it because of what it implies. I was one without her. I am one now. Save the motivational poster. I don’t need metaphysics explained to me by the sort of person who thinks “you were always valid” is a full meal. I know what I am.
But there’s knowing you’re a woman, and there’s being treated like one when your body still feels like hostile evidence.
Elise gave me that.
A woman who’s attracted to you wants your Tuesday. She wants the pharmacy calls, the laundry room, the ugly crying, the rent panic, the bad eyeliner, the head cold, the sulking after a failed reading. For a while, Elise wanted all of it. Or I thought she did.
That’s the tragedy. The beginning was real enough to make the ending feel like a betrayal of reality itself.
ii. The Girl She Could Hold
The chaser is rarely stupid about the politics, which is what makes her dangerous instead of merely embarrassing.
Elise had read the right writers. She would say trans women are women with her whole chest, in the group chat, at the reading group, underneath the repost, before I’d finished exhaling in relief. She corrected strangers’ pronouns faster than I did. She had the language. She had the posture. She had the bottle.
None of that language ever reached her desire. The desire was older than her politics, and it went on quietly filing me under almost, under extra, under more intense than the women she brought home for her mother’s birthday.
This wasn’t simple hypocrisy. Hypocrisy would almost be a relief, because hypocrisy requires the hypocrite to know she’s lying. What Elise was doing was stranger. Some part of her genuinely believed the thing she posted. Some other part of her, older and less supervised, ran on a different set of instructions. The two parts had made a private agreement never to check in with each other.
I could see the wall by noticing what she never said out loud. She described me as brave. Intense. Fierce. A lot. More than she was used to. She didn’t describe me as ordinary, because ordinary was what she reserved for women whose girlhood she never had to take on faith.
The compliments sounded like reverence. They functioned like a fence. Every one of them kept me exactly where she needed me: one step outside the category she claimed, out loud, to already believe I was in.
And still, she made me feel real. People hate this part of stories because they want the moral injury to arrive wearing a name tag. They want the bad woman to say bad things early, preferably near a mirror, so everyone can feel smart for spotting her.
But Elise was gentle. Elise was funny. Elise brought me soup when I was sick and sat on my floor reading while I slept. Elise remembered my pharmacy hours. Elise knew which side of my face I hated in pictures and never posted the bad ones.
She also loved me best when I was visibly becoming. She loved the trembling hands. The first shot. The cheap butterfly clip she bought me from a street vendor and fastened into my hair outside the train station.
“You look like a girl who ruins people,” she said.
“I’m trying to be kinder this year.”
“Tragic,” she said. “I liked the old brand.”
I wore that clip until one of the wings snapped off.
She was there when my face started changing. At first it was small. Softer skin. My cheeks filling out. The faint rearrangement of my features that made strangers pause less before choosing a pronoun. I would catch myself in windows and flinch because some girl I almost recognized was looking back at me.
Elise noticed everything.
“Your face is different,” she said one morning, touching my cheek.
“Bad different?”
“Beautiful different.”
Then she kissed the corner of my mouth, then my jaw, then the place under my ear that made my thoughts scatter.
“You’re becoming yourself.”
That sentence fed me for weeks.
When a cashier called me “miss” for the first time without hesitation, I texted Elise from outside the store with shaking hands: HE SAID MISS. She called me immediately and said, “Say it again.” I told her, “He said miss,” and she screamed so loudly I had to pull the phone away from my ear.
Then I laughed. Then I cried. Then she cried because I was crying, which at the time seemed sweet instead of ominous. She came over that night with drugstore champagne and a tiny cake that said CONGRATS GIRL in icing so ugly it looked legally actionable.
We ate it from the container with forks, sitting on my floor.
“To getting gendered correctly by men who don’t deserve to perceive you,” she said, raising her plastic cup.
“To the bare minimum.”
“The bare minimum,” she agreed.
That night she undressed me slowly, almost reverently. She kept stopping to look at me, which made me shy and furious and hungry all at once.
“Don’t stare,” I said.
“I like looking at you.”
“You’re making it weird.”
“You are weird.”
Rude, obviously, but not inaccurate enough to contest in court.
There was a way she wanted me then that felt like proof. Her desire moved over me like warm water. She touched me as if my body had become legible, as if she’d learned its grammar instead of waiting for it to match something outside me. She kissed my stomach, my breasts, my shoulders. She whispered “girl” against my skin until the word lost every clinical thing it had ever carried.
I’d never felt more real, which is why it took so long to notice when the feeling began to curdle.
iii. The Border Was the Point
Here is what she actually wanted, if you could get her honest enough to admit it, which she never would, so I’ll say it for her.
She wanted masculinity with the threat surgically removed.
More specifically, she wanted a fantasy of forced feminization with all the ugly words sanded off. She would never call it that. She’d never be caught dead admitting that some part of her desire lived in the idea of a body being softened, trained, renamed, made pretty, brought down from manhood into something she could touch without feeling like she’d betrayed herself.
She didn’t want to think of it as a fetish. Fetishes were for men with bad Reddit accounts and worse lighting. Elise had a tote bag, a reading group, and a vocabulary for harm, so naturally her private erotic life had been declared innocent by committee.
But the structure was there.
She liked the before-and-after of me. She liked that my body carried evidence of movement. She liked that my shoulders didn’t disappear just because my skin got softer. She liked that my voice could still drop when I was tired. She liked the places estrogen had changed me and the places it hadn’t finished changing me yet. She liked me most when I seemed caught between proof and possibility, when my womanhood still looked like something happening in real time, something she could witness, encourage, touch, and quietly take credit for.
That’s the part people lie about. Disgust is optional for the chaser. Sometimes transition intoxicates her instead. Feminization, for her, works best as a scene she can stand inside. She wants to watch the supposed old thing get overwritten. She wants the softness to arrive with a little trace of conquest still attached, as if womanhood were something done to me, something I’d been talked into, pushed toward, opened up into by the right woman’s hand.
She wanted to imagine herself as midwife and beneficiary at once.
A man made pretty. A man who used to be dangerous and now was not, because someone else did the cutting for her, in a doctor’s office, over months and years, on a payment plan I was still making payments toward. She got the old charge of heterosexual danger, the size difference, the shoulders, the low register she could still sometimes hear underneath mine on a bad phone connection, without ever having to call any of it heterosexual, because I carried a wristband from the clinic and a name on my ID that rendered the whole transaction legible as lesbian.
I did the labor. She collected the reward, tax-free, at a lesbian bar, wearing a shirt that said the future is female. She didn’t want a whole woman, because a whole woman isn’t a costume a man puts on after losing a fight he never agreed to enter. She wanted the border, not the country on either side of it. She wanted the transformation, not the woman who survived it.
This is a brutal thing to realize about someone who once kissed your injection site. It didn’t happen all at once.
Resentment starts small, as jokes and little adjustments, a pause before a compliment, a look you have to convince yourself you imagined.
The first time, we were at a party in someone’s third-floor apartment. I wore a black dress Elise had found for me at a thrift store. It fit better than anything I owned. My hair was longer by then. My face had softened. I’d learned eyeliner through failure and spite.
When we walked in, three people turned. They turned without any of the old inventory in it, none of the what-are-you pause. They turned the way people turn when a pretty woman enters a room.
Elise saw it. I felt her see it.
For the first hour she was fine. She got me a drink. She introduced me to someone from her reading group as “my girlfriend Mara,” and I carried that sentence around inside me like a lit match.
Then a cis girl named Tessa complimented my dress.
“You look incredible,” Tessa said.
I said thanks too quickly, like I’d stolen the compliment and expected police.
“No, seriously,” she said. “You’re so pretty.”
Elise laughed. Not loud. Not cruel. Just a small laugh from behind her cup.
Tessa looked at her. “What?”
“Nothing,” Elise said. “It’s just funny.”
“What’s funny?”
Elise smiled at me. “Mara used to hate dresses.”
I felt my face go hot.
“I didn’t hate dresses,” I said.
“You did.”
“I hated being looked at wrong in them.”
There was a silence, not huge, just enough to make the party decide something had happened.
Elise’s smile tightened. “Right. That’s what I meant.”
But it wasn’t what she meant.
Later, in the bathroom, while two drunk girls argued outside the door about whether they were toxically compatible, I asked her why she said that.
Elise asked what I meant.
“That I used to hate dresses.”
“I was teasing.”
“It felt weird.”
“You know I didn’t mean anything by it.”
“You made me sound…”
“What?”
“Like I was pretending.”
Elise’s face changed into something worse than anger. Injury.
“Mara, come on.”
“I’m telling you how it sounded.”
“You know I don’t see you that way.”
That sentence again. The emergency glass she broke whenever a conversation caught fire.
“I didn’t say you did.”
“You kind of did.”
Outside the bathroom, someone knocked. Elise snapped, “One second,” then turned back to me softer.
“I’m on your side.”
At the time, I believed being on my side meant she couldn’t be doing anything from the other side. Adorable. Nearly pastoral.
After that, she began missing the old version of me in ways she could only express through admiration. Once, lying in bed beside me, she said, “You were so bold when we met.”
“Am I not bold now?”
“You are. Just different.”
“Different how?”
“I don’t know,” she said. “You cared less what people thought.”
I turned onto my side. “I cared constantly.”
“You know what I mean.”
I did.
She missed when my womanhood looked more like defiance than arrival. She missed when loving me made her feel brave. She missed when every stranger’s confusion reflected well on her politics. Back then, walking beside me said something about her. Look at Elise, so fearless. So expansive. So queer that even her desire had footnotes.
Once I started passing, I became less useful as evidence. A pretty woman at her side was just a pretty woman at her side, with no aura attached, no visible moral adventure, no little electric scandal to collect.
I stopped being the evidence she could show people.
I became competition.
That was the part neither of us expected. It sounds petty because it was petty, and petty things can still ruin your life. Men held doors for me. Baristas smiled. Women complimented my nails without that careful pause beforehand. In public, people began treating me like a woman Elise had to stand beside rather than a thesis she got credit for understanding.
At first, she celebrated it. Then she measured herself against it. Then she resented me for winning a contest I’d never entered, judged by rules designed to kill me.
“You’re getting a lot of attention lately,” she said one night after a reading.
We were walking home. It had snowed earlier, then melted into black city slush. My boots were soaked. I was happy in the stupid way a good reading makes you happy, when strangers have laughed at the right lines.
“Am I?”
“Don’t do that.”
“What am I doing?”
“Pretending you don’t notice.”
“I notice. I don’t know what you want me to do about it.”
She stopped walking. “I don’t want you to do anything.”
“That tone usually means you do.”
“I’m just saying it’s interesting.”
“What’s interesting?”
“How much you like it.”
There are sentences that don’t slap you until hours later. This one slapped immediately.
“Being treated like a woman?”
“Being wanted.”
The streetlight made her face look sharper than it was.
“You wanted me.”
“I still do.”
“Then what are we talking about?”
She looked away. “I don’t know. Sometimes it feels like you’re disappearing into all of this.”
“What does all of this mean?”
“The passing thing. The attention. The performance.”
The performance.
I almost laughed. I almost screamed. I almost told her that she’d loved me best when womanhood looked hardest on me, when I was all edge and ache and visible labor. She’d loved me when my femininity was a bruise she could warm her hands over. Now that it was becoming a life, she called it performance.
Instead I said nothing.
That was my mistake. She spent the next month drawing conclusions I never got to cross-examine.
iv. The House Becky Keeps
Black women have had a name for her for generations, and I grew up hearing it long before I understood I would one day date her. The name is Becky. The name has a discography, but the psychology is older than any song, older than the bar, older than the country that built the bar. A Becky is a white woman whose innocence is load-bearing, whose tears are currency accepted in every court, and whose womanhood is a rank she polices rather than a life she lives.
The question that took me years to ask about Elise is the simplest one. Why was she there at all? Why the fundraisers, the stickers, the reading group, the trans girlfriend, singular and then, I would learn, plural? Nobody made her come. Nothing about her life required us. She kept showing up anyway, and I kept mistaking the showing up for love, because I didn’t yet understand that a rank is a relational object. A title with nobody underneath it is just a name. The fundraiser was her border checkpoint. She commuted to us to get the rank stamped.
White American womanhood was built as a rank, and it was built inside a house. The nineteenth century wrote the job description and called it true womanhood: piety, purity, submissiveness, domesticity, the pedestal with the good light. Every plank of it was nailed on top of a woman legally barred from all four. Purity was impossible for a woman the law would not allow to be raped. In 1855, Missouri tried an enslaved nineteen-year-old named Celia for killing the man who had owned her since she was fourteen and used her accordingly. When her lawyers reached for the statute protecting any woman from being taken by force, the court ruled that the words any woman didn’t reach her. The category had a locked door, and the lock was the point.
The mistress didn’t keep her distance from the women underneath the category. She kept them in the house, closer than she kept her own children. Dressed by them in the morning. Fanned by them at night. Her babies at their breasts. Historians spent a century selling the gentle mistress, the soft-handed lady wringing her hands at her husband’s cruelty, and then Thavolia Glymph went into the plantation records and found that the household was the mistress’s own jurisdiction, and the violence inside it was frequently hers, administered personally, over laundry, over a look.
Ladyhood was a position before it was ever a temperament, and the position was staffed. She couldn’t be the lady of the house alone. The rank was performed on top of another woman’s body, daily, at close range, which is why the proximity was never a contradiction of the hierarchy. The proximity was the hierarchy’s engine. Hortense Spillers gave the operation its grammar a century later: under that order, Black women were not gendered at all, just flesh, while woman functioned as a title, and the title required somebody female standing permanently outside it in order to mean anything.
Nothing about a bad girlfriend in a queer bar is chattel slavery, and I’m not going to insult the dead by pretending the scale compares. The inheritance sits at the level of technique. Womanhood held as a rank. Sorta like the Jedi The rank certified by the women at the high council of course but verified by the grandmaster of the order who of course is a man. Intimacy as the venue. Tears as the court of appeal.
In 1955, one white woman’s testimony about one alleged whistle put a fourteen-year-old boy in the Tallahatchie River, and the whole country learned, again, what her tears could purchase in any room she shared with us. When Elise cried and her friends closed around her in that crescent, nobody in that bar invented anything. They performed a ritual older than the building, fluently, from memory, without a single rehearsal, because the training is that deep and that old.
Hegel makes this easy to understand The master needs the slave for the one thing mastery cannot produce on its own, which is recognition. Somebody has to see the rank or the rank doesn’t exist. But the diagram has a trap built into it: recognition extracted from somebody you’ve degraded is counterfeit currency. It never spends. The moment it lands, it’s worthless, precisely because of who it came from, so the hunger resets, so the master needs the slave again in the morning, and the whole machine runs on a satisfaction that’s structurally impossible.
That’s why the Becky can’t leave. That’s why she’s at the fundraiser. She knows exactly where she is. The appetite can only be fed here, and it can never be fed at all.
Freud supplies the belief mechanics. He called it disavowal, the maneuver where a person holds two incompatible beliefs at once and never makes them fight it out. I know very well, the formula goes, but still. Elise knew very well I was a woman. She still needed me to be almost one. Both halves were sincere, and neither half was the lie, which is what made her so much harder to hold than a liar. You can’t catch a woman in a contradiction she’s genuinely never had to notice, and she’d built an entire adult life, the reading group, the water bottle, the crescent of friends, on never once having to notice it.
And underneath the disavowal, the export. Patriarchy makes every woman fail at woman. The category was designed unreachable. That’s its function, and every woman lives with a private folder of the ways she falls short of it. The Becky doesn’t open her folder. She locates a woman whose womanhood can be treated as more questionable than hers and files everything there instead. Every hour she spent supervising my womanhood was an hour she didn’t have to spend interrogating her own, and my gratitude, my visible labor, my shaking hands above a syringe, certified her from below.
Julia Serano caught half of this twenty years ago: in the cissexual imagination we get stocked on our own shelf, a third thing invented to be consumed, kept separate from the women who need no justification to be wanted. What the shelf can’t show you is who does the stocking, or why she keeps walking back down the aisle.
So here is the answer to the question. Accident, charity, even the sex: none of it explains why Elise was in our world. One thing does. Her womanhood is comparative, and comparison requires the compared, present, in the same house, preferably grateful. I got the operation twice over, the original and the remix, the Black woman’s position and the trans woman’s position running on the same engine, and I can tell you from inside both that the engine doesn’t care which fuel it burns.
She loved me best when I was easier to pity than envy, and now you know why. Pity is the rank differential experienced as an emotion. Envy is what happens when the differential closes. The differential was the thing being maintained, and I’d spent a year mistaking it for the relationship.
v. Less Finished
This is also how she kept her own house in order.
A cis woman who sleeps with men has to answer for it inside every feminist framework she’s ever posted about. A cis woman who sleeps with me got to keep the word lesbian on her dating profile, because I wasn’t a man, because she said so publicly, in writing, with a caption, and because saying so was precisely what let her feel the thing she wasn’t supposed to feel and file it somewhere else.
I wasn’t a loophole to her by accident. I was a loophole by design, the one place her self-concept and her libido were permitted to disagree without either of them having to lose the argument in front of witnesses. She got to walk through me sideways into a kind of desire her whole identity said she left behind at nineteen, then come out the other side with her lesbian card unstamped, unquestioned, fully renewed.
The last months were full of almost-fights. Almost-fights are worse than fights. A fight at least respects you enough to happen. An almost-fight never finishes, so you wear it home without noticing, and every normal sentence starts carrying a second sentence underneath it, uglier and harder to answer.
She stopped calling me “my girl.” I noticed immediately and pretended not to, which is one of the feminine arts nobody puts on a syllabus.
She still touched me, but differently. Less wonder. More claim. Her hands, once careful, became searching in a way that made me feel less desired than checked. In bed, she sometimes went quiet after, staring at the ceiling like she’d lost something and was trying to decide whether I’d stolen it.
Once, half-asleep, she said, “Do you ever miss it?”
I knew I shouldn’t ask, but I did anyway. “Miss what?”
She was silent for so long I thought she’d fallen asleep.
“Before.”
I sat up. The bedroom was dark except for the streetlight leaking through her curtains. Her face was turned away from me.
“No.”
“I didn’t mean…”
“You did.”
“I just wondered.”
“Why?”
“I don’t know.”
“Try.”
She pulled the sheet up around herself, suddenly modest, as if I’d walked in on something indecent.
“You had this energy then.”
I felt something in me go very still. “What energy?”
“I can’t explain it.”
“You can.”
“Mara.”
“Say it.”
She covered her face with one hand.
“You were less…”
“Less what?”
“Finished.”
Not a slur. Not a scream. Something worse, because it came wearing grief.
I got out of bed and started looking for my underwear. Elise told me to wait. I said no. She said it came out wrong, and I said, “It came out honest.” She sat up, crying now, because of course. The body always knows which weapon to reach for.
“I loved you before all of this,” she said.
“What does all of this mean? Me looking like myself?”
“That’s not fair.”
“It’s accurate. Fair is a luxury.”
“I’m scared I’m losing you.”
“You’re not losing me. You’re losing the version of me that made you feel brave.”
She flinched.
I’d finally said it.
The apartment changed. I don’t mean emotionally. I mean physically. The air thickened. The bookshelves looked staged. The whole place revealed itself as a set I’d mistaken for a home.
“You think I fetishized you,” she said.
“I think you loved my becoming more than you loved me.”
“That’s cruel.”
“It’s true.”
“You don’t know what’s in my head.”
“No, but I know what disappears from your face when strangers treat me like a woman before you get to explain me.”
That was the line that ended us, even though she would make it take three more weeks.
What being wanted by the chaser teaches you, after enough repetitions, is to distrust your own instruments. You start reading every future woman’s interest as possible camouflage, checking her language for the seam, and some of what you lose that way is real love that was never doing anything wrong, caught in a net you built for somebody else entirely.
That’s the quieter injury, the one almost nobody mentions: the good women you eventually flinch away from, because you got so good at spotting the loophole that you stopped trusting doors that were only ever just doors.
Ask her, sometime, what she would call it if you transitioned back tomorrow. Watch how fast the sentence stops being about you and starts being about her.
vi. Concern, With Teeth
The theater survives right up until you open your mouth about something other than her.
A whole woman has opinions about her landlord. A diagnosis she’s tired of explaining at parties. A mother who still uses the wrong name at Christmas and calls it a slip. An ex she isn’t entirely over. A rent payment due Friday that she would, actually, appreciate some help with, since we’re being honest about need in this relationship.
None of that is erotic. All of it is a woman.
A woman is never what the chaser ordered. She ordered a symbol standing very still in a doorway, backlit, hurt and grateful. The moment the symbol asks her for anything, a favor, a boundary, an apology, a real conversation about what she’s getting out of this and what it’s costing you, the doorway starts to look, to her, remarkably like an exit.
The exile began before the breakup. It always does.
First, invitations got vague. People forgot to text me. The reading group changed locations and someone “thought I knew.” A friend of Elise’s who used to hug me at every party started touching my shoulder instead, the brief pity-touch reserved for women being quietly moved from person to problem. Group chats went silent when I entered and became lively again twenty minutes after I stopped typing.
Then came the concern, which is gossip after it gets a grant.
People were worried about me. People were worried about how intense things had gotten. People wanted to make sure everyone felt safe. Everyone. That beautiful little word that always somehow means the person crying loudest, and in every scene that’s ever thrown me out, the person crying loudest has been white.
Elise cried very well.
She didn’t lie, exactly. Lying is vulgar and therefore beneath women who own linen pants. She told selected truths in an order that made her the only possible victim. She said I accused her of not seeing me as a woman. She said I mocked her sexuality. She said I became cruel after I started passing, which is a hell of a way to describe a woman noticing the terms of her own use.
She said I had changed. That part was true. I had.
My face had changed. My body had changed. My name had settled into me. My voice had found the register it could live in without bleeding. I no longer entered every gathering prepared to apologize for taking up the wrong kind of space. I’d changed because I’d survived long enough for change to reach me.
This was held against me in the court of women who called themselves abolitionists.
I have watched that exact recalibration happen on a face I loved, in real time, over a text message about splitting a phone bill. It takes less than a second. The eyes stay the same. Something behind them relocates. You learn to see it happen so many times that you start watching for it before you’ve even finished the sentence that triggers it, bracing the way you would brace for a slammed door somewhere else in the house, and the bracing stays in your body for good whether or not this particular woman ever does it to you specifically.
That’s the actual cost nobody bills you for. Not the relationship itself. The vigilance that outlives it.
This is the part nobody warns you about when they tell you to hold out for someone who really sees you. Being seen and being wanted are not the same appointment, and the chaser only ever booked one of them.
vii. The Room She Kept
You can watch the fantasy take damage in real time if you know where to look, and by now I knew where to look.
It’s in the compliment that only ever mentions your bone structure, never your argument. It’s in the specific hush she uses when she tells her friends about you, the hush people reserve for a secret vacation, not the hush people use for a relationship they intend to keep. It’s in the group chat where she calls you brave and the bedroom where she asks you to keep certain lights off.
It’s in the way her hand finds your throat, your hips, your hands, before it ever finds your eyes, running an inventory she thinks is admiration and you learned months ago to clock as a survey.
She sexualized the whole map of me, then acted hurt when I noticed the route she kept taking. Her hand liked my throat because it could call it tenderness while remembering size. Her hand liked my hips because estrogen had made them new. Her hand liked my chest because it could treat growth like a miracle she’d been invited to supervise. Her hand liked my jaw when she thought I wasn’t paying attention. She would touch the softest parts of me with wonder, then drift back toward the places she imagined still held some old charge, as if my body weren’t a body but a before-and-after photo she could keep opening in the dark.
That’s what made it so confusing. She didn’t reject my womanhood in bed. She consumed it. She praised it, kissed it, warmed her hands on it, made little noises against it. Then, beneath all that reverence, she kept looking for contrast. Soft skin over hard history. Breasts beneath shoulders she’d already mythologized. A girl’s name in a voice she could still pretend had an underlayer. She wanted the totality of me, yes, but only as long as the totality could be arranged into tension.
She called that tension chemistry.
I called it being studied.
It’s in the questions she saves for the dark that she’d never ask in daylight, about before, about the process, about what changed and when, phrased as curiosity and functioning as an appraisal, the kind you run before buying something that might not be exactly what the listing promised.
It’s in six months of public solidarity that evaporate the first time you correct her in front of people whose opinion she actually values. Then the tears arrive, right on schedule, and the people around you believe the tears before they believe you, because they always have, because a cis woman’s confusion gets protected in places where a trans woman’s clarity gets read as an attack.
She has more credibility crying about you than you’ll ever have explaining yourself, calmly, with receipts, and she knows it, even if she’d rather die than say she knows it.
The final conversation happened at the bar where we met, because queer scenes don’t believe in new locations. They keep staging your humiliation in the same four venues and calling it community memory.
There had been a meeting. I wasn’t invited to the meeting, which is how you know the meeting was about safety. Safety requires the unsafe woman to be absent so everyone can describe the danger in peace.
I found out because Tessa, God bless her nervous little heart, texted me by accident: are you coming tonight or is it better if you stay away until things settle?
I stared at the message until my vision blurred.
Until things settle.
The phrase had no subject. Things. Like weather. Like nobody made them.
I went anyway. This was stupid. This was necessary. These are often the same thing.
The bar was crowded. Same bad lighting. Same folding table by the bathrooms. Same jar labeled CASH FOR COMRADES. Elise stood near the back with her friends around her in a loose protective crescent.
She looked beautiful. I hate that part.
She had cut her hair shorter. Her eyes were red. She wore the shirt I used to steal from her, the faded black one with the collar stretched out. I knew how soft it was. I knew the tiny hole near the hem. I knew the smell of her skin after rain.
The body is disgusting. It keeps receipts the mind has already shredded.
When she saw me, her face broke open, and what poured out was fear.
That was the final humiliation. Realizing you’ve become frightening to someone who once held a needle steady in your thigh and whispered that you were allowed to be scared.
“Mara,” she said, and the whole bar shifted. You could feel everyone pretending not to listen.
“I heard there was a meeting.”
She looked down. “It wasn’t like that.”
“It never is.”
Tessa appeared beside her, pale and committed to being useless.
“Maybe this isn’t the best place,” she said.
“This is exactly the place. Apparently everybody else already got to discuss me here.”
Elise’s eyes filled. There it was. The municipal alert: CIS WOMAN TEARS IN YOUR AREA. SEEK SHELTER. FACTS MAY BECOME UNSTABLE.
“I didn’t want this,” Elise said.
“No. You just wanted to be protected from what you did.”
“I loved you.”
I almost folded right there, and I’m not going to pretty that up. I believed her grief even though I never once believed her innocence. She had loved something. She had. The tragedy was not that it was all fake. Fake would be cleaner. Fake would let me hate her without this rot in the center of it.
She loved me at the border. She loved me in the becoming. She loved my shaking hands, my first shot, my cheap butterfly clip, my voice before I learned how to stop apologizing with it. She loved the girl climbing out of the ruin. Then she resented the woman who made it out.
“I know,” I said.
Her face softened with relief, as if I’d finally agreed to return to the script.
Then I finished.
“You loved me best when I was easier to pity than envy.”
The bar went dead. Someone actually whispered, “Jesus.”
Elise started crying harder. “You’re being cruel.”
“No. I’m being accurate in public. That’s what you can’t survive.”
A woman I barely knew stepped forward. “Mara, maybe you should go.”
I laughed once. It sounded ugly.
“Of course.”
Elise said my name again.
“No, it’s perfect. Very clean. Very feminist. You got the girl, you got the story, you got the tears, and now you get the room.”
Nobody said anything.
Exile, it turns out, makes almost no sound. Nobody screams and no door slams. The silence just spreads itself over every witness until nobody has to admit they watched it happen.
I looked around at all of them. Women who had shared my cigarettes. Women who had reposted my essays. Women who had called me sister with mouths still wet from brunch. Women who knew, or could’ve known, if knowing had offered them anything.
Nobody moved.
I don’t say any of this from a safe analytical distance. I’ve sat exactly there myself, the injured party’s chair somehow occupied by the person who did the injuring, and felt my own argument, the correct one, the well-documented one, dissolve in real time against the simple fact of somebody else’s tears.
I left that bar exiled.
Watch what happens to the word ally the second it costs her something. Watch how quickly your anger becomes the story, and her fetish becomes the footnote, in a scene she’s still, somehow, allowed to leave feeling like the injured party.
viii. The Needle Without Witness
Want us without making us pay for the wanting.
I will tell you, since we’re being honest, what it’s actually felt like on my end, across every version of her I’ve dated: like being loved by someone who kept one hand on the exit the entire time, in case it turned out I was real. Like watching gratitude curdle into resentment the second I asked for something a symbol doesn’t need, a symbol being famously low-maintenance. Like grieving a relationship that, looking back, I’m not sure ever fully happened to the actual me at all.
That’s its own specific flavor of loss, mourning a woman who was standing right there the whole time and simply was not the one who got loved.
Elise wiped her face with both hands. I wanted to hate her cleanly. I could not. She was standing there in the shirt I knew, crying with the mouth I’d kissed, surrounded by people who were happy to protect her from the woman she’d helped make and then punished for arriving.
I thought of her kneeling in the kitchen with the needle. I thought of the bandage on my thigh. I thought of her saying, “Done.” She’d been right, just not in the way either of us meant.
I turned and walked out.
No one followed.
Outside, the city was wet and cold. Rain slicked the pavement. A bus hissed at the curb. Two girls smoked under the awning and stopped talking when they saw me. By morning, the story would be finished without me. It would be careful. Compassionate. Full of concern. I’d become volatile. I’d made people uncomfortable. I needed space. The scene needed boundaries. Elise was devastated, but trying to heal. Everyone hoped, in time, there could be accountability.
Accountability, in that scene, means the exile agrees she deserved the weather.
My phone buzzed with a message from Tessa: i’m sorry. i tried.
I deleted it.
Then another came from Elise: i never wanted to hurt you.
I stared at that one for a long time. Rain hit the screen and blurred the words until they looked almost honest.
I typed back, you wanted the becoming. you got angry when I arrived, but I did not send it. Some sentences are too true to waste on the people who made them necessary.
I walked home alone through the rain with my makeup running and my phone at twelve percent. My estrogen was due the next morning. For the first time since that Sunday in Elise’s kitchen, I’d have to do the shot myself.
At home, I put the pharmacy bag on the table. The apartment was dark. The radiator clanked. I sat with the vial, the syringe, the alcohol swab, the whole little altar of it.
My hands shook.
Of course they did.
I almost called her. Not because I wanted her back. I wanted the girl she’d made possible. I wanted the kitchen again. I wanted her thumb on my cheek. I wanted the version of love where being helped didn’t become debt. I wanted the woman who’d looked at my trembling body and said I was allowed to be scared.
But that woman had only existed while I was still becoming.
The woman I’d become was alone.
I cleaned my thigh, loaded the syringe, and pressed the needle in. It hurt more than when she did it. I laughed when it was over, one sharp miserable little sound, because there was nobody there to kiss the bandage and nobody there to call me brave, which meant at least nobody was there to take credit for it either.
I put the used needle away and sat on the kitchen floor until the shaking stopped.
By morning, I was out of the group chat. By noon, someone had unfollowed me. By evening, a friend of a friend posted something about how harm can come from people we romanticize as victims.
I was the harm now.
That’s how cleanly a community can turn a woman into a lesson when it gets tired of treating her like a person.
The exile didn’t kill me. I wish it had been dramatic enough to justify how much it hurt. It just made everything smaller. Fewer invitations. Fewer places to sit. Fewer people willing to meet my eyes in public. The bar stayed open. The reading group kept reading. Elise kept being loved by women who said they believed women.
And me? I kept taking estrogen. I kept passing. I kept becoming harder to use.
That was my revenge, if you can call something that lonely revenge.
Somewhere tonight there is another fundraiser with the same folding table, and Elise is handing a plastic cup to a girl three months on estrogen whose hands still shake, telling her that her writing is brutal, that she has a presence. The position I vacated is open. It’s always open. The recognition she pulls up through a trembling girl never spends, because of who she made it come from, so the hunger resets by morning and the collection resumes.
That’s the psychology of the Becky, and none of it was ever personal, which is the coldest thing I can say about the warmest year of my life.
Desire a whole woman, landlord and diagnosis and mother-who-gets-the-name-wrong included, or desire nothing at all, because there is no honest third option where you keep the charge of a man and the politics of a lesbian and hand us the difference to carry alone.
Woman enough to date. Man enough to eroticize. Marginal enough to make you feel radical standing next to her. Hurt enough to make you feel profound. That is not a relationship. That’s a costume you’ve been wearing us as, and we’ve been cold in it for a very long time, while you got to leave warm every single time.
You don’t get the scar anymore. If you want us, you get the woman, whole, with rent due and an opinion about it and a mother who needs correcting every single Christmas until she gets it right or stops being invited. If that isn’t what you came for, the door works both ways. It’s always worked both ways. We were just too grateful, for too long, to point at it.
I became a woman no one in that bar could claim they had built.
Whole, unfortunately.
Whole, finally.
And exiled for it.
If this essay was worth something to you: https://ko-fi.com/bundleofstyyx